There's Nothing Left to Give
And the Princes [heads of the tribes] brought the onyx stones, and the
stones to be set for the ephod and the breastplate." (35:27)
Rabbi Shlomo Yitzchaki quotes a Medrash, which elaborates: this is the
totality of what they brought. The princes brought nothing else, because
the rest of the nation -- the "regular people" -- brought everything
necessary to build the entire Tabernacle ("And the work was sufficient for
all the construction, in order to do it, and more" [36:7]). Nothing was
left for the princes to give, save the stones for the breastplate!
The Medrash records: Rabbi Nosson said, why is it that the Princes gave
first at the Dedication of the Tabernacle, whereas when it came to the
actual construction, they did the opposite? The answer is that the Princes
said: let the congregation give what they will give, and whatever remains,
we will fill in. The nation then brought everything that was needed. This
being the case, the princes said "what is left for us to do?" -- and they
brought the precious stones. And for this reason, they gave first when it
came time to dedicate the Tabernacle. They didn't want to make the same
Imagine a congregation building a new synagogue today. What would happen
if a donor offered to "finish the job" after the other congregants had
contributed whatever they wished? Obviously, the board would jump for joy.
The synagogue would be built! And in fact, this would most likely inspire
a more relaxed (i.e. lazy) attitude on the part of the fundraiser and the
other congregants -- after all, the money was as good as theirs already,
due to the generous man or woman in the back. But according to the
Medrash, it was the Princes who were guilty of laziness -- and perhaps
they underestimated the dedication of the people at large.
The Nation of Israel did not want to give up the opportunity to be part of
the Temple. They didn't hold back, and wait to see what others would do.
Nor did they rely on the Princes' guarantee. Each one said: I want to
participate! It didn't matter that the work would be done without them -
on the contrary, no one wanted to be left out. Each one saw an opportunity
to give, to contribute to the benefit of the entire Jewish nation, and did
so. And they gave so much that there was extra. They gave so much that
Moshe found it necessary to instructions out to the people to stop giving
[36:6], assuring us that had he not done so, they wouldn't have stopped
for a good while longer.
The Chofetz Chaim of Radin notes that the Torah indicates the laziness of
the Princes by dropping an optional letter "Yud" ordinarily found in the
Hebrew word "Nesi'im," Princes. By contrast, the Torah describes in full
detail the gifts of each Prince at the Dedication of the Tabernacle --
even though each of the twelve brought precisely the same gift as all the
others. All of this, he explains, is to teach us the greatness before G-d
of working together, with energy and dedication, rather than allowing
feelings of superiority or jealousy to divide us. When people rush forward
to work on behalf of the entire group -- instead of holding themselves
above others, or looking out for their personal interests -- then this is
valued dearly by G-d, the Torah... and by other people, as well.
Rabbi Yaakov Menken
Text Copyright © 2004 by Torah.org.
The author is the Director of Project Genesis - Torah.org.
About the Author